California Maritime Attorney - A Passenger Injury Case Study - Learn Boat Accident Law from a California Maritime Lawyer - - This article is a case study of a passenger boating injury. A maritime legal analysis is performed in order to illustrate boat accident liability and maritime law principals. This is a case study of a recreational boating accident in California. However, the principals discussed here apply to all inland navigable waters of the United States. California Maritime Lawyer, Los Angeles Maritime Lawyer, San Francisco Maritime Lawyer, Riverside Maritime Lawyer, San Bernardino Maritime Lawyer, Orange County Maritime Lawyer, San Jose Maritime Lawyer, Sacramento Maritime Lawyer, Bay Area Maritime Lawyer, Inland Empire Maritime Lawyer, California Maritime Attorney, Los Angeles Maritime Attorney, San Francisco Maritime Attorney, Riverside Maritime Attorney, San Bernardino Maritime Attorney, Orange County Maritime Attorney, San Jose Maritime Attorney, Sacramento Maritime Attorney, Bay Area Maritime Attorney, Inland Empire Maritime Attorney

A Passenger Injury Case Study


Maritime Lawyer Passenger Injury

California Maritime Attorney - A Passenger Injury Case Study

If you or a family member are seriously injured in a California boating accident, it is important for you to understand maritime law. This article is a case study of a passenger boating injury. A maritime legal analysis is performed in order to illustrate boat accident liability and maritime law principals. This is a case study of a recreational boating accident in California. However, the principals discussed here apply to all inland navigable waters of the United States.


A Case Study - Passenger is Injured Due to Jumping a Large Wake

It is a nice Saturday summer afternoon in San Diego. A 27 foot Sea Ray is cruising on San Diego Harbor. There are 5 people aboard the Sea Ray. Two thirty-something local men and three twenty-something women visiting from Chicago. The guys are taking the Chicago tourists for a sight seeing cruise on the Bay. They take a lazy circle around Embarcadero Marine Park - then they head back out onto the Bay.

The owner of the Sea Ray is operating the boat. One woman is sitting in the bow area and the rest of the passengers are seated in the cockpit and stern. No one is really paying much attention. They are engaged in conversation.

A 46' Bertram is cruising past the Embarcadero, about 300 yards away. The Bertram is going 10 -15 mph and putting out a decent size wake.

As he clears the jetty, the Sea Ray operator doesn't see any vessels directly in front him so he speeds up to 25 mph. With the afternoon chop, the Sea Ray is probably going too fast for the conditions. The student in the bow is gamely trying to hold on while looking back toward the stern. The Sea Ray Operator is distracted. He suddenly looks up and sees the wake from the Bertram.

The Sea Ray operator in an apparent attempt to cowboy or show off, guns the I/O and tries to jump the Bertram's wake. The Sea Ray gets partially airborne. When the vessel slams down, the forward seated woman lands awkwardly. She slams into the Sea Rays deck. The Sea Ray operator slows down, but the Sea Ray hits the next two wakes hard. The Chicago tourist lands hard on the deck after each wake.


Tourist is Seriously Injured

The woman's leg fractures in three places. She has spiral comminuted fractures of both the tibia and fibula. After open reduction, there was shortening of the leg. She had a series of surgeries and rehabilitation stints. She has significant residual permanent impairment. Her medical bills total over $120,000.


Maritime Law Analysis

First, under general maritime law, the Sea Ray operator owed the passengers a duty of reasonable care under the circumstances. It was not reasonable to attempt to jump the wake of the Bertram. Thus, the Sea Ray operator breached his duty of care to the passengers. The breach of the duty of care was a direct cause of her serious personal injuries.

Second, although there was no "collision" - the operator of the Sea Ray is in technical violation of Rules of the Road. Here, the Inland Rules apply. The Operator is in violation of Rule 5 Lookout. Every vessel shall at all times maintain a proper lookout. The Sea Ray operator was distracted and did not properly observe the cruise's wake. The operator is in violation of Rule 6 - Safe Speed. All vessels must proceed at a safe speed at all times. The Sea Ray was going too fast for the conditions.


Case Result:

After a lawsuit was filed and depositions were taken of all the people on the Sea Ray the case quickly settled out of court. The Sea Ray was well insured. The Sea Ray's insurance carrier paid the policy limits of the Sea Ray's owners insurance policy.


Disclaimer:

The foregoing is a California boat accident case study. It is not legal advice. Any resemblance to actual events, persons and/or vessels is purely coincidental. I am simplistic in order to achieve clarity. Each boat accident case is different and has separate challenges, difficulties and/or nuances. There is no guarantee that your California boating accident case will have a similar result as discussed in this vessel collision case study.

California Maritime Lawyer, Los Angeles Maritime Lawyer, San Francisco Maritime Lawyer, Riverside Maritime Lawyer, San Bernardino Maritime Lawyer, Orange County Maritime Lawyer, San Jose Maritime Lawyer, Sacramento Maritime Lawyer, Bay Area Maritime Lawyer, Inland Empire Maritime Lawyer, California Maritime Attorney, Los Angeles Maritime Attorney, San Francisco Maritime Attorney, Riverside Maritime Attorney, San Bernardino Maritime Attorney, Orange County Maritime Attorney, San Jose Maritime Attorney, Sacramento Maritime Attorney, Bay Area Maritime Attorney, Inland Empire Maritime Attorney




The Turley Law Firm Attorneys accept cases in the following locations in California: Los Angeles, San Diego, San Jose, San Francisco, Fresno, Long Beach, Sacramento, Oakland, Santa Ana, Anaheim, Bakersfield, Riverside,  El Cajon, Vista, Stockton, Chula Vista, Fremont, Irvine, Modesto, Glendale, San Bernardino, Huntington Beach, Oxnard, Fontana, Moreno Valley, Oceanside, Rancho Cucamonga, Santa Clarita, Garden Grove, Ontario, Pomona, Santa Rosa, Salinas, Palmdale, Hayward, Pasadena, Torrance, Corona, Lancaster, Catalina Island, Bodega Bay, Bethel Island, Half Moon Bay, Eureka, Avalon,  Escondido, Alameda, Orange, Elk Grove, Sunnyvale, Fullerton, Thousand Oaks, El Monte, Simi Valley, Concord, Visalia, Vallejo, Ventura, Ventura Harbor, Marina del Ray, Morro Bay, Inglewood, Santa Clara, Pacific Ocean,  Port of Los Angeles, Port of Long Beach , Port of San Pedro, Santa Barbara, Santa Barbara Channel, San Clemente Island,  San Joaquin River, San Francisco Harbor, San Francisco Bay, Stockton, Port of Stockton, Port of Sacramento, Port San Luis, California Delta, Lake Tahoe, Colorado River, Port of San Diego, Sausalito, Santa Cruz, San Pedro,  San Diego Harbor, Stockton, Oceanside Harbor, Catalina Island, Dan Point, Newport Harbor, Ventura Harbor, Port Hueneme, Vallejo, Crescent City, Yuba City, Wilmington, and the Channel Islands, and the navigable waterways of the the United States and the navigable waters of California.

The Turley Law Firm handles all type of boat and ship accidents and we are boat accident attorneys, including Jones Act attorneys, unseaworthiness attorneys, boat negligence attorneys, maintenance and cure attorneys,  cruise ship attorneys, recreational boating attorneys, boat accident attorneys, ship accident attorney, boat collision attorney, ship collision attorney, barge accident attorney, barge attorney, derrick attonrey, floating work platform attorney,  PWC accident attorney, personal watercraft accident attorney, sailboat accident attorney, water ski accident attorney, sailing accident attorney,  tanker attorney, offshore attorney,  and river accident attorneys.  Jones Act Attorney,  Jones Act Lawyer, Boating Accident Attorney, Boating Accident Lawyer, LHWCA Lawyer, LHWCA Attorney, Longshore Act Attorney, Longshore Act Lawyer.





Practice Areas:


    ©2010 The Turley Law Firm, All Rights Reserved
    The Turley Law Firm website and all its contents are copyrighted. All articles, photos and graphics may not be reproduced, republished, retransmitted or redistributed without prior written permission.

The Turley Law Firm
626 Broadway, Suite 625
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: (619) 234-2833
Fax: (619) 234-4048
Toll Free: 866-963-0540


The San Diego, California personal injury law firm of The Turley Law Firm serves clients across  Southern California area. We give you straight talk about your legal options. We have handled cases from San Diego to Imperial Beach to Oceanside to Escondido to El Cajon, everywhere in between, such as: Alpine, Camp Pendleton, Cardiff, Carlsbad, Chula Vista, Coronado,  Del Mar, Eastlake, Encinitas, La Mesa, La Costa, La Jolla, Lakeside, Lemon Grove, Mission Bay, NAS San Diego, National City, Naval Station San Diego, North Island, North County, Pacific Beach, Point Loma, Port of San Diego, Poway, Ramona, Rancho Bernardo, Rancho Santa Fe, San Marcos, San Diego Harbor, Santee, Solana Beach, South Bay, Spring Valley, Vista.

We handle cases across California, including: Riverside County, San Bernardino County, Orange County, Imperial County, Los Angeles County, and Ventura County, Colorado River, Mexico, Cabo, Pacific Ocean and all the Oceans and waterways across California and the World.


Work Accident Lawyer San Diego l  San Diego Jones Act Attorney I San Diego Boat Accident Attorney I San Diego Ship Accident Attorney I San Diego Longshore Act Attorney I San Diego Defense Base Act Attorney I San Diego Product Liability Attorney I San Diego Wage and Hour Class Action Attorney, San Diego Toyota Attorney I San Diego Catastrophic Injury Attorney I San Diego Disability Insurance Attorney I San Diego Unum, Unumprovident & Paul Revere Attorney



William Turley

©2012 The Turley Law Firm, All Rights Reserved, Reproduced with Permission Privacy Policy
Attorney web design by Foster Web Marketing, the best attorney website design solution on the Web offering search engine optimization for attorneys, lawyer website design, video for attorneys, and more.
Get SEO Tips from The Attorney Internet Marketing Blog